(Photo courtesy of Alfredo Rico)
August 28, 2025
By Alfredo Rico
Affiliate Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We earn from qualifying purchases.
After reviewing a ton of red dots over the years, I can understand why choosing a pistol-mounted topic is so difficult. The arena is saturated with a ton of companies and models. Adding to the dilemma is that competition in the budget and mid-tier segments has improved the quality across the board. Choosing a top 5 is a difficult endeavor. I started with a top 15 and made notes on each. I then whittled them down from there based on two criteria. The first are those red dots that I keep at hand when testing pistols, and the second is those that sit permanently on my most often used pistols.
5. Swampfox Liberty II (Photo courtesy of Alfredo Rico) The $259 Liberty II is my first exposure to Swampfox. Generally, when I see a red dot at this price, my expectations are low, and I’m highly skeptical about quality and function. My first impressions were very good. The attention to detail on the packaging design carried its way onto the red dot. The black box uses matte and gloss finishes with a silver-foiled product name and logo.
The dot is 3 MOA and runs an RMR footprint. The hood of the housing is the thickest of the red dots in the list. The rear of the hood carries serrations, which reduce glare. Serrations are also found around the lower half of the brightness control buttons. The buttons sit on the left and right sides of the unit. They are pronounced enough to activate with shooting gloves but not so pronounced that they will be easily activated when pressed flat against a surface. The buttons control 10 illumination settings.
Advertisement
An important feature I look for is a low rear deck. The Liberty II sits low enough to clear the stock sights of a Shadow Systems MR920. It saves me from buying taller sights. Another detail I liked was the top-loading battery cover. It’s removed using a hex wrench. A hex key doesn’t have any play in it which makes starting the tiny threads on these circular caps much easier than on cross-keyed caps.
Turrets can be funky on red dots. Sometimes the click types don’t click, sometimes the friction types spin too easily. The Liberty II offers the right resistance to make accurate adjustments. I discovered this when I zeroed the optic. After I shot my first group, I was about three inches high and left. I looked at the turret marks and dialed in the elevation and windage. I was dead on my first try. Pounding the Liberty II on the wooden shooting table did no damage, and the dot kept its zero. The model I evaluated was the red dot version, but it is also offered in a dedicated green dot or red multi-reticle. It has a waterproof rating of IPX7.
4. Riton 3 Tactix MPRD 3 (Photo courtesy of Alfredo Rico) The Riton 3 Tactix MPRD 3 is a multi-reticle red dot with an RMSc footprint. Its slim design makes a great companion to a micro-compact pistol. The reticle selection is a 3 MOA dot, 30 MOA circle, and 30 MOA circle with 3 MOA dot. I found the 30 MOA circle and 3 MOA dot to be my favorite of the three for this small optic. With the pistol fully drawn, the 30 MOA circle takes up a third of the window space. It is surprisingly fast to center on a target. There are 10 brightness settings controlled by adjacent buttons on the left side of the unit. 2 of the settings are night vision compatible. It includes an auto-awake feature. I’ve disabled this feature on some red dots because the motion sensor is sluggish. No here, it works superbly.
Advertisement
One of the odd details is that the side-loading battery compartment is held in place by friction and takes some jostling to slide it out. It has stayed flush since I’ve been using it. I’ve bounced this around on various pistols and it’s proven to be a workhorse. The MPRD 3 is the red dot I mount when I’m testing on a micro compact pistol.
3. Holosun Ronin HS5507Comp-RD (Photo courtesy of Alredo Rico) I included the Ronin HS5507Comp because it has a humongous window. Priced at $465, its 1.1 x .87-inch window gives the shooter a larger unobstructed view of the target. This makes it ideal for multi-target engagement. It too utilizes a multi-reticle system, giving the user a choice between a 2 MOA dot, a 32 MOA circle, and a 2 MOA dot with a 32 MOA circle. The fine 2 MOA allows for precision placement on near to mid-distance targets. The reticle has 8 brightness settings, two of which are night vision compatible.
Although it is marketed as a do-it-all optic, its size makes it the most suitable on a competition or training pistol. The base utilizes an RMR footprint and its battery is sideloading. Of important note is that it was designed in collaboration with Tu Lam of Ronin Tactics. Lam is a retired Special Forces Green Beret and a professional tactics and weapons expert. The right side of the housing displays a relief of a dragon, Ronin Tactic’s logo.
2. Vortex Defender CCW (Photo courtesy of Alfredo Rico) The Vortex Defender CCW achieved its high position because of its build quality and features. Its $350 price did not give it an edge. The Defender is also available in a larger model called the ST and costs $450. The CCW is for pistols with an RMSc footprint and the ST with pistols having a DeltaPoint Pro footprint. The CCW is available in a 3 MOA red, 6 MOA red dot, or 3 MOA green dot. The 8 brightness settings, 2 of which are night vision compatible. The ST shares the same red dot options as the CCW model.
The rest of the Defender features are similar too. Pronounced buttons on the left and right of the housing are easy to detect and offer a sharp click. The window size is generous, which gives a large field of view within the glass. The housing is robust and features a ShockShield, a polymer bumper insert that helps soften the force of hard impacts. Machined into the face of the hood are cross-sectional grooves called Fast-Rack. The aggressive texture allows the face of the housing to grasp even slick surfaces when racking the slide on them. Vortex’s CCW has seen heavy use. It has earned my trust, and it’s why it stays planted on my main self-defense pistol.
1. Trijicon SRO (Photo courtesy of Alfredo Rico) The Trijicon SRO is at the top spot because it’s been working flawlessly on my training pistol since 2019. It’s followed me through a multitude of training classes with no hiccups. I also have the RMR HD on another training pistol, but I favor the view through SRO’s large round window. The round window provides the least obstructed view of the target. The SRO is available in a 1 MOA, 2.5 MOA, or 5 MOA dot and in red or green dots. Brightness is controlled via large buttons on the sides of the unit or can be set to auto-brightness. The only issue I have come across is when using a Duracell CR2320 battery with a child-safe bitter coating. The coating is thick enough to prevent the battery cover from threading. Regardless, at $822 the SRO is the priciest of the red dots on my list but worth every penny.
Top Selling Handguns Sold in August 2025 Source: gungenius.com/top-selling/
To learn more or shop for any of the guns listed, visit Gun Genius at www.gungenius.com/top-selling .
Editor's note: In the report, guns are rated from one to five within each category, with the number one gun being the most popular that month. The numbers are color-coded to show any changes in the ranks from the previous report.
Black = Steady Green = Up Red = Down
Source: gungenius.com/top-selling/
To learn more or shop for any of the guns listed, visit Gun Genius at www.gungenius.com/top-selling .