#5--Blood Diamond (2006)--"Don’t run, you’ll only die tired"
I walked into this movie not expecting much more than a drama, maybe with a little action, and was blown away. I wasn’t the only one, and it garnered 5 Academy Award nominations. Not only is it an excellent drama about the African diamond trade, it features a spot-on performance by (whodathunkit?) Leonardo DiCaprio as a mercenary. The climax of the movie is itself an excellent scene, and arguably the best in the movie, but not the most realistic—that has to go to another.
DiCaprio and Djimon Hounsou are trying to make their way cross country without getting killed, and come to a bridge they have to cross with two guards. DiCaprio is armed only with a pistol, the sentries AK-47s. Using a ruse DiCaprio gets to within about 10 yards of the guards and then centerpunches each of them. He then shoots each of them once more as they lay on the ground. A third guard pops his head out, sees what happened, and takes off running. Instead of running after him with his pistol, DiCaprio calmly walks up to a fallen guard, picks up his rifle, and takes the fleeing guard down at distance with a carefully aimed three round burst. Admittedly, not much of a gunfight as DiCaprio was the only one to get off any rounds, but isn't that a good sign you're doing things the right way?
YouTube has age restricted this scene. You can view the clip here.
#4--Proof of Life (2000)--"Go Loud"
Proof of Life is another one of those movies where I went in not expecting much and was totally blown away. Russell Crowe stars as a former SAS operator now working K&R (Kidnap and ransom) jobs for an insurance company—his job is to negotiate a deal to get the person back safely. Meg Ryan stars as the wife of the kidnapped American executive.
This movie didn’t do as well as hoped for at the box office, even with the combined star power of Crowe and Ryan. I know why—it’s realistic! Crowe spends most of the movie on the phone trying to negotiate for the safe release of the hostage, and even though he is attracted to Meg Ryan’s character, he’s a complete professional and doesn’t act on it. There were rumors flying around at the time that the same thing didn’t happen off camera, and maybe some moviegoers were hoping for some steamy onscreen action. They got it, but maybe it wasn’t the kind of action they were hoping for.
Through a fluke of luck Crowe discovers the location of the guerrilla base camp where the hostage is being held. He assembles a small team, with the hope of getting the hostage out without firing a shot—and they almost succeed. Tactics, weapons handling, mindset, planning—all of it is spot on, even down to the proper way to cut a sentry’s throat. David Caruso has a small but great role as an adrenaline junkie with a yen for short-barrel Benelli shotguns.
#3The Kingdom (2007)--"This is a Very Bad Neighborhood"
Having a bit role in Michael Mann’s Collateral just before helming this film was a very good thing for Director Peter Berg, because he apparently went above and beyond to ensure technical accuracy in what is essentially a police procedural…..sort of.
When terrorists attack the American compound in Saudi Arabia, an FBI evidence team headed by Jamie Foxx manages to convince the Saudi authorities to let them help with the investigation of the bomb site. Most of the movie is the characters butting heads with the locals while trying to do their jobs in a politically-charged situation.
While the movie starts with an engaging action scene, what will blow you away is the climax which starts with a car chase into a neighborhood from hell. The characters have to rescue one of their own (Jason Bateman) who is destined to be beheaded on camera. Imagine having to do a houseclearing…only it’s not a house, it’s an entire apartment building, filled with terrorists armed with AKs and RPGs. One of the things I liked best about this movie was the little details of the climax, like Bateman fighting and fighting and fighting, even when tied up and all seems lost, because he knows what’s going to happen.
#2--The Way of the Gun (2000)--"Free Cheese"
The Way of the Gun is a tough movie to watch, because the main characters (played by Ryan Phillippe and Benicio del Toro) are not good guys at all, and neither is anybody else you’ll meet in this movie. The plot centers around the kidnapping of a pregnant Juliette Lewis, who is tied to a shady organized crime figure played by James Caan.
This movie could have gone a lot of ways, most of them b-movie bad, but if I remember my trivia right the brother of the director (Christopher McQuarrie) was a Navy SEAL, and pretty much lived with the actors. If I had to pick a movie that was closest to 100% realistic in weapons handling from start to finish, The Way of the Gun would be it. A great example of this is a scene where Benicio del Toro exchanges words with someone in a parking lot, and fires a round off. As soon as he heads back into the motel room, while talking to his partner, you see him topping off his magazine!
The climax of this movie is a rather lengthy gunfight involving a lot of people at a run-down hotel south of the border. You’ll see the proper use of a tactical sling, one-handed reloads, the proper way to clear a room with a .308, and a lot more. But like I said, nobody in this movie has clean hands, and things don’t end well for anyone.
#1--Heat (1995)--Bank Heist
The bank robbery scene from Michael Mann’s epic Heat is probably the best movie gunfight—of any kind, realistic or not—made to date. The fact that it is just one of at least four gun-heavy beautiful and awesome action scenes in this movie (one of which I covered earlier, the Drive-In scene) is amazing.
Everything about this scene is golden, and, as usual, Mann does everything as technically perfect as humanly possible. The suspense has built throughout this movie until this scene, which is still only two-thirds of the way through its three-hour running length.
DeNiro and his team have successfully robbed a bank without having to fire a shot and are just getting into their car when Val Kilmer sees members of the LAPD’s Robbery Homicide unit running up on them, and then all hell breaks loose.
Guns are loud, and guns in movies should be loud. Mann startled the heck out of people in the theater when Kilmer in a relatively quiet moment out of the blue opens up on full auto without hesitation, and it is LOUD. When their getaway car (and driver) are taken out, DeNiro and Kilmer and Tom Sizemore do their best to get the hell out of there. The sound of DeNiro's/Kilmer's Colt Commandos echoing off the buildings in downtown L.A. is perfect.
If when you watched this movie you were yelling at the characters because they weren’t hitting much of anything on full auto, you are missing the point—they were engaging in suppressive fire, trying to break contact and keep the officers’ heads down while they made their escape. That was why they continued to pour full-auto fire at every target—that is the proper technique to use if you want to break out of an ambush. They weren’t (necessarily) trying to kill anybody. SAS veteran Andy McNabb was the technical advisor on this movie, and you have him to thank for Val Kilmer’s impressive mag changes with his carbine.
This movie will always have a spot in my heart, if for no other reason than I saw it with three very close friends. At the time I was a police officer, and one of my friends was a DEA Agent, the other a SWAT Team sniper. We knew we shouldn’t be rooting for the bad guys, but Mann really made it tough…..
Though it is much newer…Act of Valor featured guys who seemed to know what they were doing (for obvious reasons…).
The Professional showed both sides of the gun-handling issues: Leon hit what he was aiming at…the spray-&-pray crowd didn't hit much of anything most of the times.
There are others…but those are my votes.
Alan_T
I agree whole heartedly with you Wolvie about Unforgiven .
RAB
Apparently, their full autos never run out of ammo. I have never seen so many rounds come out of 20rd mags.
2WarAbnVet
Re #1: Hollywood leads the ignorant to believe that the streets are filled with automatic weapons.
Mango
I can't believe that Sinners and Saints didn't make the cut. Slow movie, but the gun scenes are worth the watch.
Alan_T
Ok …… I know this is Mr . Tarr's list and it's subjective , so in essence it's neither right nor wrong …. BUT , the only one I would have picked was Way of the Gun . Now to be fair , I didn't see Blood Diamond or Proof of Life BUT …… The Kingdom ? Really ? It' was an ok movie ….. but realistic gun fights ? …… If you say so . One movie I do believe could have been included that starred BOTH Leonardo Di Caprio and Russel Crowe we Body of Lies , a way better choice than The Kingdom , in my opinion . To parrot Mr . Tarr " Leonardo Di Caprio who'da thunk it ? "Like Wolvie , I think Unforgiven would have made a better choice . Oddly , The Godfather , had very little in the way of gun fights considering the theme , but what there was , was extremely realistic . Maybe the most realistic , now that I think about it . Who can forget Vito Coreleone ( yes I know I probably didn;t spell the last name correctly ) getting gunned down in the street after being ambushed buying from the fruit & vegetable stands while 'Freddo whimpers and cowers next to the car ? ANYWAY …. you gave us something to talk about Mr . Tarr , thank you .
James Tarr
Picking only 10 was very tough. If I was picking the top 30 or so, Unforgiven would definitely have made the list, as would L.A. Confidential. The Godfather too, that's a good choice. But……I had to pick 10, and probably I'll get as many people disagreeing with me when I pick the 10 best war movies….
Alan_T
I know it was , Mr . Tarr ( that;s because along with being increadably handsome , talented , wealthy …. [ did I mention handsome ? ] ….. I'm smart ! ! ! ) . AHEM …… Anyway ….. go by the old axiom of , " you can't please everyone " . You're always worth reading and , once again , thanks for giving us something to talk about .
Alan_T
Now that I think about it ……. I'm not really wealthy ….. I guess …. uh ….. probably not the other things so much either …… uh ……. I guess .
chuck
RONIN wasn't bad, Deniro again. As for some movies that are NOT- I have seen movies where the goodguy has a pistol & 6-8 guys shootin' at him with autos, figure what- 2500 rounds per minute minimum (combined)? they miss with every round but he gets 3-4 of em on the run with a semi-auto. I usually turn the movie off about then.
Alan_T
RONIN is one of my favorite movies ….. I don't know that I would have nominated for it's realistic gunfights , but it was a GREAT movie Chuck . I agree , La La Land has a bizarre set physics laws when it comes to guns , accuracy , effectiveness , lethality and probability !
T.D. Honeycutt
I love James Caan and Geoffrey Lewis in this movie because they are snubbie guys. Caan comes to a gunfight with a J frame .38.
Alan_T
Yep , I agree T . D . , I don't remember Cann's exact quote but i have to go along with it , " Whenever you see some miserable , broken – down old man in the game , the one thing you can count on is he's a survivor . " ( or words to that effect ) HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
reaganmarine84
Am I the only one that believes the final scene of "Tears of the Sun" deserves the #1 spot. That is absolutely spot on. Also would like to mention "Bravo Two Zero"
John
WTF
John
Rambo 1st blood I guess
Eric
Collateral should of been on here, although he is crazy, Tom Cruise was spot on with his shooting. A surprising sight was that he actually reloaded his weapon after firing a few rounds, don't see that everyday in hollywood!
scott
Just came across this article, my two cents: The Getaway remake with Alec Baldwin and Kim Basinger- the final confrontation in the hotel, very suspenseful and Kim does a great job of reloading under stress; for a western how about Silverado with Kevin Kline, Scott Glenn(USMC Force Recon RT), Danny Glover, and Kevin Costner, the scene where Glenn's character is practicing for the showdown is quite well done; as for war movies Hamburger Hill, Viet Nam era movie with a lot of young actors who went on from there to lengthy careers. Sort of a poor mans Platoon. And one of my all time favorite movies Grosse Pointe Blank with John Cusack, while it is considered a "dark comedy" the weapons work and fight scenes are really well done. And finally, something more recent The Bourne Legacy with Jeremy Renner, better than average.