The Guns & Ammo Network



A Special 1911

I have to admit I was worried. I’m pretty tight with a buck, and ponying up the money it takes to buy an Ed Brown 1911 for a model I’d only handled but never actually fired was a stretch for me. But over the years it’s been my pleasure to chat with Ed at trade shows, and I was able to borrow an excellent rifle from his company for a once-in-a-lifetime trip to Tanzania for Cape buffalo. (Not buying that .375 H&H after the trip ranks as one of my great firearm blunders of all time, especially since Ed’s now out of the rifle biz, and I regret it to this day.) Plus, of course, I’m well aware of his company’s reputation as a top-flight gun builder.

No, what worried me was that I’d get my usual case of buyer’s remorse, the feeling that I’d foolishly spent too much money for something I didn’t really need. But as my fellow Californians know, time is slipping away. 1911s don’t lend themselves to the features the state requires in order for a new handgun to be on the “approved” list—particularly the magazine disconnect requirement. Therefore, it will soon be nearly impossible to purchase a new 1911 in this state.

The author’s new Ed Brown Special Forces 1911 is everything it’s cracked up to be.

The author’s new Ed Brown Special Forces 1911 is everything it’s cracked up to be.

Time is running out on me as well, or at least as I look at 50 years old I feel that way. So I told myself, “Dammit, buy yourself a really good 1911 before it’s too late,” and for the reasons I mentioned previously—as well as thinking back on all the 1911 reviews I’d edited over the past several years at Guns & Ammo and now Handguns, along with what I’d learned from firing various 1911s at press events or those belonging to friends—I sent in my deposit for an Ed Brown California-approved Special Forces model.

No sooner had I done that than I read Jim Tarr’s review of the brand new Special Forces Grey in the August/September issue of Handguns—the same gun I’d ordered but with a gray Gen III finish. In his article, Tarr was slightly critical of Ed Brown’s Chainlink pattern, saying it provided great lateral control but perhaps not as good vertical control as traditional checkering.

Funny how seeds of doubt grow in direct proportion to cash outlay, and I worried that maybe I wouldn’t be as happy with the gun as I’d hoped. Then I got the call from Turners gun shop that the pistol had arrived, and 10 days after filling out the paperwork, I rushed home with my prize. And the moment I pulled the pistol out of its soft case, I was pretty sure buyer’s remorse was not going to be a problem.

For one, the gun is just beautiful, from the matte black Gen III finish to the tasteful “Ed Brown” on the slide, to the gorgeous checkered wood grips. Every line on the gun perfectly executed. I belted on a holster and did a few draws and some dry-firing. Smooth—-no issues with the grip safety as I occasionally have with other 1911s. The ambi safety snicks on and off with precision, and the trigger…well, it’s exquisite.

The next day I headed to Angeles Range to start breaking it in. No accuracy test, no serious function firing, no drills. Just hang a target and shoot my new gun. It was awesome. Any reservations I had about the Chainlink were gone, and there wasn’t a single “new-gun” malfunction.

I think I did good.

  • Scott E. Mayer

    The question, of course, is does the Mrs. think you did good? LOL! Nice gun, Rupp!

    • Scott Rupp

      She finally gets tired of me waffling, "Should I? Shouldn't I?" and tells me to just get off my butt and go buy the damned thing. I'm a lucky guy.

  • Michael Geller

    I've had my Ed Brown Special Forces Carry model for about 2 weeks now and went through the very same $$$ doubts. As in your case, as soon as the work of art showed up at my local FFL, all reservations disappeared. Quality, classy, smooth and a pleasure to shoot. Now, I need to live up to the gun's accuracy capabilities!

  • Gillian Hodge

    Angeles huh? I suppose I should renew my subscription. :) I like knowing there's a local on the pages of my favorite magazine. My husband and I get pissy about all the shining reviews on firearms we can only dream about here in Los Angeles. But he's in the market for a 1911, and suffering a similar dilemma about price. Ed's beauty just isn't in the budget for people like us. He has his eye on a Kimber Custom II TLE, I think. How does Kimber sit with you?

    • Scott Rupp

      I actually don't have much experience with Kimber 1911s, but I hear that people who own them really love them. I don't think you can go wrong there.

    • Mike Chapman

      I love mine; the spring is one tight son of a gun. Feels a lot more than 16 Lbs. But I nothing but praise for the Kimber line. It will take care of you if you take care of it!

  • JGus

    Gillian, I own three Kimbers, one of them a Custom II. Your husband will love it. It's an outstanding gun.

    I have a custom made 1911 with Les Baer Frame, Colt Gold Cup slide, Ed Brown grip safety, Wilson internals, etc. Just a smooth, sweet all around gun. And the Kimber Custom II feels just as smooth to a Average Joe shooter like myself. If I was a top notch shooter I'd probably notice a difference. But being a weekend shooter on the farm I don't notice much difference at all..

    I also have a Ruger SR1911 that has far exceeded my expectations. A much better gun than the price ($650) would indicate. I'd compare it to lower end Kimber and Smith & Wesson.

  • BroncoBob

    I recently bought a Kimber Warior, the gun is realy great the gun shoots dead on.this is the fifth kimber that iv'e owned, I've dreamed of owning A Ed Brown maby one day,but until that day comes I'm satisfied with Kimber.

  • http://www.signatureholsters.com Stephen Lamanen

    If John Moses Browning were alive today, he would go to Ed Brown to manufacture his designs… this family owned business team is the real deal. Mr. Brown holds the complete resume:

    • Competitive Shooter

    • CAD/CAM skilled trades

    • Gunsmith

    God Bless America and the NRA!

  • Les maynard

    I own several Kimbers and they all have been great. I also wanted a Ed Brown Kobra Carry SS which I finally ordered and found it to be the most accurate and best finished 1911 I have ever purchased. I am now selling some of my Kimbers to help fund another Ed brown,this time a Blued Executive Elite.

  • David Johanensen

    Sooo….. how much??

  • Samurai Cowboy

    $2345.00 for a handgun is ridiculous. Anyone who spends that kinsd of money need to be reported to the IRS.

  • Nam Marine

    Nice gun. Lot's of money! I am VERY happy with my Colt series 80 in Stainless steel for $800. A 1911 should be a Colt. Everything else is ……well, just something else!

  • dave

    did u buy it , if so this is a good review….all to often editors right reviews of pistol that were given to them to test and evaluate …wright reviews ….but im think hard of buying one

  • Nam Marine

    A 1911 is either a Colt, or it's just a copy!

  • MIKE

    COME ON NAM MARINE. I WAS IN THE CORPS TOO AND IN THE SAME WAR AND SHOT THE SAME COLT MADE GOVERNMENT ISSUE WHILE AT BOOT CAMP AND ITR AND LATER IN MY UNIT BUT I HAVE TO DISAGREE WITH YOU. I OWN WILSON COMBATS AND ED BROWNS 1911'S AND THEY ARE JUST AN IMPROVEMENT OVER THE SAME PISTOL ( AS THEY DAMN WELL SHOULD BE FOR A PRICE MULTIPLE OF 3).

    EB AND WC REMAIN FAITHFUL TO JOHN MOSES BROWNING BUT USE BETTER BARRELS, MORE ADVANCED MACHINING, AND BETTER CORROSION RESISTANCE. YOUR CHOICE OF THE WORD COPY CHEAPENS THESE 2 COMPANIES PRODUCTS. ITS LIKE SAYING A SHELBY MUSTANG IS JUST A COPY OF A REGULAR MUSTANG. NOT SO……THEY ARE AN IMPROVEMENT ALBEIT AT MUCH COST.

    SEMPER FI